popnews.com

[Gildas]

un top assez ridicule à mon avis...

Drowned In Sound : Critics Poll 2003

1. Radiohead Hail to the Thief
2. The Darkness Permission to Land
3. Cat Power You Are Free
4. Blood Brothers Burn Piano Island, Burn
5. Muse Absolution
6. Fountains Of Wayne Welcome Interstate Managers
7. Funeral For A Friend Casually Dressed and in Deep Conversation
8. Zwan Mary Star of the Sea
9. Hell Is For Heroes The Neon Handshake
10. Elbow Cast of Thousands
11. Mogwai Happy Songs for Happy People
12. Outkast Speakerboxxx / The Love Below
13. Mars Volta De-loused in the Comatorium
14. Hot Hot Heat Make up the Breakdown
15. White Stripes Elephant
16. Dizzee Rascal Boy in Da Corner
17. Jane’s Addiction Strays
18. Deftones Deftones
19. Mew Frengers
20. Evan Dando Baby I’m Bored
21. Strokes Room on Fire
22. The Distillers Coral Fang
23. Goldfrapp Black Cherry
24. Rilo Kiley The Execution of All Things
25. Silver Mt Zion This is our punk rock: thee rusted satellites gather + sing
26. Twilight Singers Blackberry Belle
27. Broken Family Band Cold Water Songs
28. Biffy Clyro The Vertigo of Bliss
29. Oceansize Effloresce
30. British Sea Power The Decline Of..
31. Stellastarr Stellastarr
32. Pretty Girls Make Graves The New Romance
33. Dandy Warhols Welcome to the Monkey House
34. Alkaline Trio Good Mourning
35. Marilyn Manson The Golden Age of Grotesque
36. UNKLE Never Never Land
37. Snow Patrol The Final Straw
38. Yeah Yeah Yeahs Fever to Tell
39. Broken Social Scene You Forgot it in People
40. A Perfect Circle Thirteenth Step
41. My Morning Jacket It Stll Moves
42. King Geedorah Take Me to Your Leader
43. Blur Think Tank
44. Postal Service Give Up
45. Girls Aloud Sound of the Underground
46. Rapture Echoes
47. Metallica St. Anger
48. Cooper Temple Clause Kick Up The Fire and Let The Flames Break Loose
49. Aereogramme Sleep and Release
50. Brand New Deja Entendu
51. Rufus Wainwright Want One
52. The Shins Chutes Too Narrow On Import. UK Release March 2004
53. Distophia Soda Lake
54. Hidden Cameras The Smell of Our Own
55. Azure Ray Hold on Love
56. Four Tet Rounds
57. Belle And Sebastian Dear Catastrophe Waitress
58. M83 Dead Cities Red Seas and Lost Ghosts
59. Billy Talent Billy Talent
60. B Movie Heroes Anthems for the Underdog
61. Ani DiFranco Evolve
62. Magnet On Your Side
63. Warlocks Phoenix
64. Desert Sessions Volumes 9 & 10
65. Clearlake Cedars
66. Black Rebel Motorcycle… Take them on, on Your Own
67. Sole Selling live Water
68. Meanwhile, Back In Communist Russia… My Elixir: My Poison
69. Jetplane Landing Once like a Spark
70. Super Furry Animals Phantom Power
71. Adam Green Friends of Mine
72. Thursday War all the Time
73. Peaches Fatherfucker
74. The Kills Keep on your Mean Side
75. Adult Anxiety Always

The Science Bit...
This chart was compiled from the votes of our staff, who chose their top 20 albums of the year, with number 1 scoring 20 points and number 20 scoring 1 point. There was a two vote minimum to get into the chart. Radiohead scored nearly 200 points.
_________________
If we were in Jail, You'd be my bitch...

[Julien]

Ceux en rouge sont ceux que tu approuves ?

Bon, sur ce que je vois, disons que la hiérarchie est assez convenue, mais il me semble qu'on peut faire pire comme top de fin d'année - y a quand même les Shins, Super Furry, British Sea Power, Fountains of Wayne...
_________________
Come on, there must be more to life
Than cutting corners with the butter knife

[cusmar]

snow patrol et postal service dans le top 50
c'est plutôt cool

je trouve finalement je ne le trouve pas aussi convenu que cela ce classement.

bon il y a les deftones, jane's addiction, marylin manson et quelques autres fautes de gout mais d'ensemble c'est pas mal.

Il faut revoir le classement d'adam green et B&S trop bas